If you, too, are that type of cook, you’ll be set with the highest scoring olive oil in our roundup: Monini GranFruttato Extra-Virgin Olive Oil. Monini Premium Extra Virgin Olive Oil $40 at AmazonBest budget-friendly olive oil: Colavita Italian BlendWe found this Italian olive oil floral with a nice aroma and a touch of peppery flavor. Colavita Premium Italian Extra-Virgin Olive Oil $13 at AmazonWe also liked Merula Extra-Virgin Olive Oil. California Olive Ranch Extra Virgin Olive Oil $8 at TargetBest midrange olive oil: Monini D.O.P. Olive Oil Jones Siena Tuscan Early Harvest Extra-Virgin Olive Oil $18 at Olive Oil JonesBest olive oil splurge (grassy and tannic): Brightland AliveInstead of spring grass, this Instagram star has an essence of grass clippings and wet leaves.